The Protein Myth: Why High-Protein Diets Aren’t Bad for Your Liver or Kidneys (And Might Even Help You)

For decades, so-called “health experts” have warned us: “Don’t eat too much protein—it’s going to wreck your kidneys and overload your liver.” But is this really true? Let’s look at what the latest research actually says.
​
Where Did the Protein Warnings Come From? Most of the fear around protein and organ damage comes from early studies on patients already living with severe kidney disease—not healthy, active people. These results were picked up and repeated until they became “common sense.” But when we review controlled clinical trials and population studies, a totally different story emerges.

What Science Really Says About Protein, the Liver & KidneysHigh-Protein Diets and Liver Health

• Liver Fat Reduction: Multiple clinical studies have shown that high-protein diets (with or without calorie restriction) can dramatically reduce liver fat in people at risk for non-alcoholic fatty liver disease (NAFLD)—sometimes by over 40% in just weeks. These effects come from protein’s ability to suppress genes that create and store fat in the liver.
• Muscle Preservation: For those with existing liver problems, extra protein is not only safe—it’s recommended to help maintain muscle and prevent malnutrition.

High-protein diets reduce liver fat—Summary, German Diabetes Center (DZD)
Randomized Study: High-protein diets melt liver fat (Liver International, 2020)
Comprehensive NAFLD Review (Frontiers in Nutrition, 2022)
Plant vs Animal Protein for Liver (ScienceDirect, 2016)

High-Protein Diets and Kidney Health

• Healthy Kidneys: Large reviews have found NO harm from higher protein intake in people with normal kidney function—no increase in kidney damage markers, no chronic kidney disease (CKD), and possibly even a lower risk of CKD with more protein (especially plant-based).
• If You Already Have CKD or Major Risk Factors: If you’re living with kidney disease, high protein might accelerate loss of kidney function, so caution and medical guidance are smart.

Systematic Review: Protein & Healthy Kidneys (ScienceDirect, 2018)
High Protein Linked to Lower CKD Risk (Frontiers in Nutrition, 2024)
Mayo Clinic FAQ: High Protein Diets and Kidneys

​Animal vs. Plant Protein: Animal proteins (red and processed meats) may increase kidney workload in people already at risk, while plant protein is neutral or beneficial. Varied sources—like fish, eggs, dairy, beans, and lentils—are ideal. 

The Real Bottom Line:

• For healthy, active adults: High-protein diets support muscle growth, fat loss, and metabolic health—they aren’t harmful to your liver or kidneys.
• Worried about kidney damage? There’s simply no convincing evidence for harm—unless you already have significant kidney dysfunction.
• If you have kidney disease: Work with your doctor or dietitian for a tailored plan.